Why this book?
- It defines a clear and useful concept, "capitalist realism," that makes it easier to analyze today's culture and politics.
- It presents the 2008 banking crisis and the bank bailouts as an example of this ideology at work.
- With the concept of "reflexive impotence," it explains why people know capitalism's flaws and still feel unable to act.
- It reveals the links between neoliberalism, bureaucracy, education and mental illness.
- Rather than relying on utopias, it directs critique to the system's own points of failure, such as climate change and mental health.
About the book
Capitalist Realism by Mark Fisher, the British theorist and cultural critic, was first published in 2009 and has been translated into Persian by Reyhaneh Abdi. Gamān Publishing has issued the translation. The original subtitle, "Is There No Alternative?", alludes to Margaret Thatcher's slogan "There is no alternative."
Fisher, with a nod to the term "socialist realism," defines "capitalist realism" as a pervasive sense that capitalism is the only viable political and economic system and that even imagining a coherent alternative to it has become impossible. He sees this sense not as confined to art and advertising but as an atmosphere that conditions the production of culture, the regulation of work and education, and hangs over thought and action like an invisible barrier. His examples in the book include the film Children of Men and the 2008 banking crisis, in which the state, whose shrinking neoliberal ideologues had long called for, moved swiftly to rescue the banking system.
Among the book's other concepts is "reflexive impotence," a condition in which people know capitalism's flaws but believe there is no way to change it. Fisher also speaks of "business ontology," a logic that understands goals solely in business terms and spreads into education and public services. To critique this ideology, he draws on Jacques Lacan's distinction between the Real and ideological "realities," and he identifies climate change, mental health and bureaucracy as places where the gaps in this narrative become visible.
The book is written for readers interested in philosophy and sociology, and it is a good starting point for anyone who wants to understand the relationship between culture, politics and everyday life in the age of neoliberalism.
Seeing the world of Children of Men must remind us of a quotation attributed to Fredric Jameson and Slavoj Žižek: it is easier to imagine the end of the world than the end of capitalism. This aphorism captures well what I mean by "capitalist realism": the pervasive sense that not only is capitalism the only viable political and economic system, but that it is now impossible even to imagine a coherent alternative to it. There was a time when apocalyptic films and novels were an exercise in cultivating the imagination: the catastrophes these works depicted were in fact narrative preludes to the emergence of different ways of human life and activity. But in Children of Men this is not so. The world shown in the film seems less an alternative to our world than a forecast of things getting ever worse in the future. In the film's world, as in ours, extreme authoritarianism and capital are by no means at odds: detention camps and chain coffee shops go on existing side by side. In Children of Men, public space has been abandoned and handed over to animals and heaps of garbage (one of the film's most shocking scenes takes place in an abandoned school through which a deer bounds). Neoliberals, the paradigm of capitalist realism, celebrate the destruction of public space; but in Children of Men, contrary to the neoliberals' official hopes, the state has not withered away, but has merely returned to its inherent military and policing function (I say "official" hopes because neoliberalism secretly relies on the state even while ideologically hammering it. This was displayed in extraordinary fashion in the 2008 banking crisis, when the state answered the call of neoliberal ideologues and rushed swiftly into the fray to rescue the banking system).Capitalist Realism
