Does being the firstborn, the middle child or the youngest really shape who we are? Extensive research shows that, contrary to popular belief, birth order does little to predict the lasting traits of personality. What matters more is life experience, our social environment and our capacity to change, because, contrary to the old assumption, human personality remains flexible throughout life.

Many of us assign particular personality traits to each position in the family: the firstborn who wants to control everything, the middle child who plays mediator and peacemaker, and the youngest who always seems ready to take a risk.
But researchers who have tested these simple, seemingly obvious predictions against statistical data from millions of people have repeatedly arrived at a similar conclusion: birth order has little power to predict the lasting traits of personality. Guessing someone's personality from their place in the birth order is about as reliable as astrology.
Of course, our position in the birth order can affect the course of our lives; but it does not determine that unique combination of thoughts, feelings and behaviors that makes up our identity. As I have written before, younger siblings, on average, fare worse than firstborns on a range of measures, including lifetime earnings and level of education. Differences in the attention and time parents devote to each child, and perhaps even more so, exposure to severe respiratory infections, can affect a child's development, with effects that persist for decades.
Human personality is usually assumed to be stable. Researchers say that five relatively stable traits, known as the "Big Five," offer a good description of our personality across cultures: extraversion; agreeableness (including empathy, respect and trust); conscientiousness (orderliness and responsibility); neuroticism (anxiety, depression and emotional instability); and openness to experience (imagination and curiosity).
Scientists once believed that by adulthood these five traits merge into a relatively fixed and stable "self," after which only slight changes in personality occur. But new research on personality is revising that view.
Ted Schwaba, a psychologist and assistant professor at Michigan State University who studies personality development and behavioral genetics, says birth order is not an important factor in shaping lasting personality traits. Contrary to the notion that personality takes shape at the moment of birth and remains unchangeable, two decades of research have shown that personality is far more flexible than we once thought. "People always have the capacity to change," Schwaba says.
Our personality changes over the course of life, sometimes dramatically. Personal experiences, conscious effort to change, and even the quiet passing of years can transform us. According to Schwaba, in most people neuroticism gradually declines; that is, they become less prone to anxiety, sadness, worry, anger and guilt. He regards this trend as the strongest evidence that a personality trait can change, and says: "Given that I struggle with anxiety myself, this finding is the most hopeful of all."
Below, we look at what scientists say about the effect of birth order and other factors on our behavior, and what really matters for understanding personality.
Siblings can foster cooperative and collaborative behavior. This is the very hypothesis put forward about the middle child: being placed between siblings may make them a conciliator, someone who, in the process of accommodating the needs of others, learns to calm disputes and behave in an agreeable and honest way.
To test this hypothesis, Michael Ashton and Kibeom Lee, professors at Brock University in Ontario and the University of Calgary, examined data from more than 710,000 people to see how birth order and family structure relate to personality in adulthood.
Instead of the Big Five, they used a different assessment tool called the HEXACO Personality Inventory. This model, in effect, adds one trait to a modified version of the Big Five: "honesty-humility," a trait associated with fairness, modesty and an unwillingness to exploit others.
The results of the study, published in 2024 in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, at first glance match what many of us would expect: people who have both older and younger siblings score higher on honesty-humility and agreeableness. The more children in the family, the higher these scores. Middle children scored highest, followed by younger siblings; firstborns and only children were at the bottom of the range.[1]
But there was an important catch: the overall effect of these differences was not striking. The number of children in the family and the number of siblings mattered more than a person's position in the birth order. Even that factor explained only about one percent or less of the observed differences in adults' honesty-humility and agreeableness scores.
If birth order really shaped personality, differences between siblings should remain apparent as they age; but this was not the case.
For this reason, the authors of another study raised a second possibility: perhaps what we know as the "youngest-child personality" or "middle-child personality" is really a set of behaviors we display in childhood, within the family setting, but drop after leaving home.
To examine this possibility, researchers turned to the question of whether younger siblings are more inclined than older ones toward risky behavior. Their reasoning rested on evolutionary theory: when siblings compete with one another for parental attention and resources, younger children may take more risks in order to compete with older, stronger siblings. In other words, the youngest child's evolutionary niche in the family may be the role of the "rebellious, adventurous child."
Tomás Lejarraga of the Max Planck Institute for Human Development in Berlin and his colleagues analyzed survey results from tens of thousands of children and adults aged 10 to 39 in the United States and Germany. They also accounted for factors such as the number of children in the family, gender, year of birth and the mother's level of education, to see how well birth order could predict a tendency toward risk-taking.
The initial result was as expected: according to a study published in 2023 in the scientific journal Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences, children aged 10 to 14 who were the younger siblings in their families showed more risk-taking behavior than firstborns. But with age, this difference gradually faded. In their twenties, birth order still had a very slight effect on a person's tendency to take risks, but by their thirties the effect had vanished entirely. This finding suggests that the youngest child's reputation for recklessness is not necessarily a sign of an enduring personality trait; it may simply be a behavioral response to their environment and circumstances. When the environment changes, our behavior changes too.[2]
Younger siblings take more risks until they leave home
Original article chart title: Estimated extent of greater risk-taking among younger siblings compared with firstborns, by age group. Data are from Germany and the United States; source: Lejarraga et al., 2023.
This result is consistent with the findings of other studies over the past two decades: our personality may remain relatively constant over a few years, but over decades it is neither fixed nor unchangeable. We are more complex than we think; over short periods we still seem like the same familiar person, but our personality can be profoundly transformed over a lifetime, especially if we want it to be.
When I asked Schwaba at what age human personality finally matures and settles, he gave no clear answer. "The truth is that people are never fully formed and finished," he said.
In the early years of life, personality is highly flexible. High school students are a clear example. According to researchers, the decisive period of personality development is usually between the ages of 18 and 25. After that, personality stability gradually increases and reaches a relatively steady level around age 30. Later, as a career, family life and stable social circles take shape, personality too usually settles into a relatively steady course.
After age 60, personality changes pick up speed again, and sometimes part of the earlier increase in conscientiousness and extraversion is even reversed. At the same time, however, another important thing happens: emotional stability, the opposite of neuroticism, continues to increase, lasting at least into one's seventies, even as our physical abilities or social resources decline.
For some people this trend leads to what researchers call the "paradox of aging": despite the body's decline, the sense of meaning and emotional well-being in life grow. Challenges that once might have provoked negative reactions may now be met with greater calm and composure. "It seems to take a lifetime to finally learn these things," Schwaba says, "but overall, the older we get, the less neurotic we become."
We do not yet know all the factors behind this trend, but we do know something about some of them.
No single gene is responsible for shaping personality; even so, personality cannot be explained without considering genetics. According to an important 2015 study, twin studies show that 40 to 60 percent of the differences between individuals in personality traits can be explained by their genetic makeup. Adopted siblings are not as similar in personality as siblings who share a genetic link. "In other words," Schwaba says, "siblings tend to resemble each other, but the reason is not merely growing up in a shared home."[3]
Even so, separating the contribution of heredity from that of environment is no simple matter. Elliot Tucker-Drob, a professor of psychology at the University of Texas at Austin, warns that determining the exact share of genetic and environmental factors is practically impossible. The two are so intertwined that they probably amplify or dampen each other's effects through interactions we do not fully understand and may never fully grasp; it is like trying to separate the ingredients of a drink that has already been mixed.
"Separating heredity from environment may be something that gets discussed a lot in online debates," Schwaba says, "but that is not how scientists actually approach the subject."
Life events are another factor in personality change. Of course, not everyone experiences life events in the same way, but it has long been assumed that major events can alter the course of certain personality traits. According to a 2024 study of 25 life events, written by Keely Dugan, a professor of psychology at the University of Missouri, and her colleagues and published in the Journal of Personality, divorce, the birth of a child, retirement, engagement, marriage and a demotion at work, in that order, were most strongly associated with personality change.[4]
But it is not only major events that change our personality; small events can matter too. For example, doing special things for a spouse five times over three years can apparently have an effect on personality similar to, or even greater than, a single big event such as marriage. "When small events are repeated many times over time, their cumulative effect grows to be comparable," Dugan writes.
She adds: "The pride we feel in personal achievements and time spent with friends and family may, taken together, have a greater effect than a wedding day or the finalizing of a divorce."
And finally, effort and perseverance enter the picture. People change, but change requires time, sustained effort and commitment. "There is good evidence that targeted interventions can really produce meaningful changes in personality," Tucker-Drob says. He points to a meta-analysis of more than 200 studies of interventions such as psychotherapy or behavioral exercises, which in some cases led to "dramatic personality change" over time.[5]
Reading self-help books alone is not enough. What has produced meaningful, lasting results is regular, difficult practice: a series of behavioral challenges such as clear action plans based on an "if... then..." pattern, daily journaling to review and reflect on one's behavior, phone reminders and similar measures. According to that research, these methods have been especially effective in reducing neuroticism and increasing extraversion.
"When people decide to work on changing themselves in this way," Schwaba says, "they succeed in surprising ways."
Of course, personality cannot be changed completely all at once. The overall patterns of thoughts, feelings and behaviors remain to some extent. It is unlikely that a very shy person will become the most outgoing and sociable member of their circle of friends; but most people change over time. Despite exceptions who may remain irritable and disagreeable, the change is usually for the better. Rodica Damian, an associate professor of psychology at the University of Houston, writes: "On average, all of us become more conscientious, more emotionally stable and more agreeable as time passes."
A smaller share of what makes us who we are, contrary to what was once believed, is predetermined. Our personality is like a natural landscape: over the years it remains recognizable, yet the forces around us and, if we wish, our own conscious effort continually reshape it.
Source: Michael J. Coren, "Birth Order Doesn't Predict Our Personality — So What Does Shape It?", The Washington Post, October 6, 2026.
[1]Michael Ashton and Kibeom Lee, a study on the relationship between birth order, family structure and adult personality, published in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 2024. The Washington Post article reports the volume of data examined as more than 710,000 people.
[2]Tomás Lejarraga et al., a study on birth order and risky behavior in children and adults, published in Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences, 2023.
[3]The original text refers to a 2015 review study on the role of genetic factors in personality differences.
[4]Keely Dugan et al., a study on the association of 25 major life events with personality change, published in Journal of Personality, 2024.
[5]The author refers to a meta-analysis of more than 200 studies on psychological and behavioral interventions.
Psychology
Psychology
Psychology
Psychology
Psychology




Discussion0 comments
No comments yet; let yours be the first voice.